The National Association of Catholic Chaplains

Menu
  • Membership
      • Apply for Membership
      • Frequently-Asked Questions about Membership
      • Request Retired Membership
      • State Liaisons
      • Newest Members
      • Membership Directory
      • Member map
      • Celebrating Our Members’ 25-year Membership and Certification
      • In Memoriam: deceased NACC members
    • Close
  • Certification
    • Initial Certification
      • Board Certified Chaplain (BCC)
      • Certified Associate Chaplain
      • Palliative Care and Hospice Advanced Certification (PCHAC)
      • VA Initial Board Certification
      • Recognition of Strategic Partners Certification
      • Newly Certified Chaplains
      • Close
    • Renewal of Certification
    • Certification Competencies & Procedures
      • Certification Competencies & Procedures
      • Important Background on NACC Certification Competencies
      • Professional Code of Ethics for Spiritual Care Professionals
      • Certification Commission
      • Certification Appeals Panel
      • Ethics Appeals Panel
      • Close
    • Mentors
    • Recognition of Strategic Partners Certification
    • Verifying Certification
    • Maintaining Certification in Retirement
    • Graduate Theological Programs
    • Close
  • Education Resources
      • 2023 Retreat
      • 2023 Webinar Series
      • Recorded webinars (2009-2022)
      • Calendar of Events
      • Graduate Theological Programs
      • CPE Programs
      • NACC Professional Networking Calls
      • Continuing Education Hour Requests – Guidelines and Forms
      • Ongoing Educational Opportunities
      • Local/Regional Gatherings & Events
      • Past Conferences (2004 – 2022)
      • Vision
    • Close
  • Resources
    • Antiracism Resources
    • Administrator Resources
    • Awareness Resources
    • Chaplaincy Care Resources
    • Coronavirus Resources & Updates
    • Job Listings
    • The Journal of Pastoral Care & Counseling
    • Partners in Pastoral Care
    • Research
    • Specialty Care Resources
    • Spirituality and Prayer Resources
    • Spiritual Care Department Resources
    • Vision
    • Close
  • About NACC
    • About the NACC
      • Mission/Vision/Values
      • Constitution and ByLaws
      • Strategic Plan
      • History
      • Close
    • Annual Awards
    • Association Leadership
      • NACC Board of Directors
      • Committees, Commissions, and Panels
      • National Office Staff
      • Episcopal Advisory Council
      • Close
    • Catholic Prison Ministries Coalition (CPMC)
    • Choose Chaplaincy
    • Health Care Collaborators
    • NACC Merchandise
    • NACC Publications and Documents
      • Vision
      • NACC Now
      • Annual Reports & Financial Reviews
      • Documents and publications
      • NACC Blog
      • Close
    • Partners in Pastoral Care
    • Partners for Professional Excellence in Spiritual Care
    • Vision
    • Close
  • Choose Chaplaincy
  • Contact Us
      • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

    • Close
  • Donate Now
  • Member Login
Home » Vision » Vision, March/April 2023 » Healthcare chaplains learn to be adept at code-switching

Healthcare chaplains learn to be adept at code-switching

By Donna Foley

One of the first pastoral visits I made in skilled nursing was to a woman religious. After I introduced myself, she responded, “You are very welcome here.” We began talking, and as she reflected on her vocation, she said, “We were told that if we left everything behind for Jesus, we would receive a hundredfold.” Opening her hands, she leaned back a bit in her wheelchair. Over the hum of her oxygen concentrator, she quietly concluded, “This is my hundredfold.” No hint of bitterness or irony was in her expression.

But when I sat down to write a useful chart note to the rest of the medical team, essentially I had to switch languages. And something was lost in translation. When I write for medicine, I am working in a second language. While I would like to imagine my colleagues and I share a common understanding of spirituality, neither of us should assume this.

In linguistics, code-switching is the practice of shifting from one manner of communication to another, depending on the social context or conversational setting. It was originally studied in terms of second-language acquisition. Most of us likely proved quite good at acquiring clinical speech as our second language.

In today’s medical world, the chaplain must show that her spiritual assessment has clinical value, but her colleagues need not show their clinical assessments have spiritual value. We face the challenge of finding common language, even in Catholic medical institutions like the ones where I’ve worked.

But lately I’ve been wondering, have we also adopted a spiritual language from medicine? The healthcare setting itself contains its own operative, but unstated, spiritual values. By “spiritual values,” I am not referring to Catholic social teaching in organizational practice (code-switching at its best), but rather conclusions about spirituality from within Western medicine.

In The Anticipatory Corpse: Medicine, Power, and the Care of the Dying, physician-philosopher Jeffrey Bishop argues that the discourse of psychiatric and medical practitioners emerging in the mid-to-late 1970s subsumed spirituality into the purview of medicine, leaving religion to the representatives of particular communities. He notes it is possible to trace in this discourse how the previous biomedical model was developed into the biopsychosocial one, and further expanded to the biopsychosocialspiritual model in current use.

One problem with this approach, I would suggest, is that it depends on an individualistic, ahistorical definition of spirituality. The resulting categories for spiritual assessment generally treat spirituality as one coping option among many, untethered to communal sources or obligations.

Chaplains explore whether the beliefs of patients or residents provide peace, meaning, or hope. In my experience, this understanding of spirituality is suited to a healthcare setting. But without knowing the flavor and content of particular traditions (even abandoned ones), misunderstandings can occur. This is where a chaplain’s code-switching ability comes in.

And medicine deems some manifestations of spiritual coping healthier than others. For example, in psychologist Kenneth Pargament’s Religious Coping Index (RCOPE), one set of items relates to belief in the devil (e.g., “The devil caused my cancer”). In the RCOPE scheme, this belief is classified as “negative religious coping.” It is “negative” in the sense that it is a harmful belief for the patient to hold, especially in relation to the patient’s health.

However, in “A Theological Assessment of Spiritual Assessments,” Harvard Medical School researcher Michael Balboni relates how in one study of terminally ill cancer patients, a belief that the devil caused cancer was “the only statistically significant question in Pargament’s RCOPE to be associated with better psychological outcomes.” Balboni writes that this finding “suggests that certain patients psychologically benefit by a theodicy which absolves God from blame and focuses on other spiritual sources as cancer’s cause.”

Without coming down on one side or the other in this particular question, it is enough to catch sight of the assumptions in this assessment tool. The researchers who developed the RCOPE seem to have a theological, as opposed to a psychological, position about what constitutes harmful belief.

At one care conference I attended, an elderly resident was asked, “And Frank, what is your goal for yourself?” He responded brightly, “To get to heaven!” The nurse recording notes exclaimed, “Oh no, Frank. You mustn’t say that. We want you here!” Frank was not expressing any harmful ideation, just his life’s real goal. It was in this conference, and in conversation with the nurse afterwards, that I began reflecting on the two different spiritualities operating in this care conference – the nurse’s and Frank’s.

Trained chaplains listen with their hearts’ ears to the people they visit and translate what they hear for interdisciplinary teams. The dominant language of healthcare – however holistic it strives to be – cannot entirely master the multiple, particular dialects of spirituality. So chaplains will need to continue skillfully code-switching.

Donna Foley, DMin, is a pastoral care team member at Saint Joseph Villa in Flourtown, PA.

The National Association of Catholic Chaplains
Become a Member Would you like to get Certified?

Free Publications

Don’t miss the latest news, subscribe to our newsletter today! You don’t have to be a member to subscribe.

National Association of Catholic Chaplains
4915 S. Howell Avenue, Suite 501
Milwaukee, WI 53207
Get Directions

Phone: (414) 483-4898
Fax: (414) 483-6712
Email: info@nacc.org

Our office hours
Mon-Thur 8:00am – 5:00pm Central Time
Friday 8:00am – 12 Noon
Sat-Sun closed

Job Listings

Current job opportunities for chaplains, priests, CPE residents, supervisors, directors of pastoral care, managers, mission directors, and more.

Job Listings

Free Publications

Don’t miss the latest news, subscribe to our newsletter today! You don’t have to be a member to subscribe.

Donate Now

Learn more about making a tax-deductible donation to NACC.

Donate Now

Connect with us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
© 1997 - 2023 National Association of Catholic Chaplains - Sitemap

Built by Westwords