The National Association of Catholic Chaplains

Menu
  • Membership
      • Apply for Membership
      • Frequently-Asked Questions about Membership
      • Request Retired Membership
      • State Liaisons
      • Newest Members
      • Membership Directory
      • Member map
      • Celebrating Our Members’ 25-year Membership and Certification
      • In Memoriam: deceased NACC members
    • Close
  • Certification
    • Initial Certification
      • Board Certified Chaplain (BCC)
      • Certified Associate Chaplain
      • Palliative Care and Hospice Advanced Certification (PCHAC)
      • VA Initial Board Certification
      • Recognition of Strategic Partners Certification
      • Newly Certified Chaplains
      • Close
    • Renewal of Certification
    • Certification Competencies & Procedures
      • Certification Competencies & Procedures
      • Important Background on NACC Certification Competencies
      • Professional Code of Ethics for Spiritual Care Professionals
      • Certification Commission
      • Certification Appeals Panel
      • Ethics Appeals Panel
      • Close
    • Mentors
    • Recognition of Strategic Partners Certification
    • Verifying Certification
    • Maintaining Certification in Retirement
    • Graduate Theological Programs
    • Close
  • Education Resources
      • 2023 Retreat
      • 2023 Webinar Series
      • Recorded webinars (2009-2022)
      • Calendar of Events
      • Graduate Theological Programs
      • CPE Programs
      • NACC Professional Networking Calls
      • Continuing Education Hour Requests – Guidelines and Forms
      • Ongoing Educational Opportunities
      • Local/Regional Gatherings & Events
      • Past Conferences (2004 – 2022)
      • Vision
    • Close
  • Resources
    • Antiracism Resources
    • Administrator Resources
    • Awareness Resources
    • Chaplaincy Care Resources
    • Coronavirus Resources & Updates
    • Job Listings
    • The Journal of Pastoral Care & Counseling
    • Partners in Pastoral Care
    • Research
    • Specialty Care Resources
    • Spirituality and Prayer Resources
    • Spiritual Care Department Resources
    • Vision
    • Close
  • About NACC
    • About the NACC
      • Mission/Vision/Values
      • Constitution and ByLaws
      • Strategic Plan
      • History
      • Close
    • Annual Awards
    • Association Leadership
      • NACC Board of Directors
      • Committees, Commissions, and Panels
      • National Office Staff
      • Episcopal Advisory Council
      • Close
    • Catholic Prison Ministries Coalition (CPMC)
    • Choose Chaplaincy
    • Health Care Collaborators
    • NACC Merchandise
    • NACC Publications and Documents
      • Vision
      • NACC Now
      • Annual Reports & Financial Reviews
      • Documents and publications
      • NACC Blog
      • Close
    • Partners in Pastoral Care
    • Partners for Professional Excellence in Spiritual Care
    • Vision
    • Close
  • Choose Chaplaincy
  • Contact Us
      • This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

    • Close
  • Donate Now
  • Member Login
Home » Vision » March-April 2020 » Ethics of organ donation range across many realms

Ethics of organ donation range across many realms

By Steven J. Squires

It is impossible to cover all the ethical dimensions of a complex issue such as organ donation in a short space, but we will look at some key considerations using the structure Jack Glaser’s three realms of ethics.

Societal (including the Universal Church)
Global ethics issues include consent or lack thereof by donors, transplantation from one species to another, and scarcity and commodification (buying, selling) of organs. In the U.S., commodification is illegal. Donation follows one of two paths – living or deceased.

Ethics discussions around deceased donation cover a wide range of concerns. Family objections cannot trump first-person consent in some states, despite dubious, prior “informed” first-person processes such as driver’s license branches. Hospital protocols all maintain the difficult perceptual balance between providers and others not harming in life while performing acts of charity after death. The “dead donor rule,” definitions of death by neurological criteria vs. circulatory criteria, and organ procurement organizations all play a role in the ethical balance.

Death is a process, not an event. Ethics discussions can also include the attending physicians preparing a dying patient for transplant with interventions of little to no benefit to the patient, as well as issues surrounding the proper amount of time needed to harvest vital organs after circulation irreversibly ceases.

However, the breadth of ideology within the Catholic Church about organ donation has perceptually narrowed over time. Pope John Paul II framed all donations as “acts of self-giving love” and “praiseworthy” in Evangelium Vitae in 1995 and his address to the International Congress of the Transplantation Society in 2000. Around 40 years earlier, Pope Pius XII said in a 1956 address that a person can use his or her body (after death) for morally useful purposes, including the aid of others. Parish church bulletins often reinforce the selfless love of organ donation as modeling Jesus’ agapeic love and healing. Chaplains can assuage patients and families with Gospel interpretation, or Church teaching. These are exemplars of selfless, morally praiseworthy acts.

The breadth of ideology within the Catholic Church about organ donation has perceptually narrowed over time.

Organizational (including the U.S. bishops)
The scope of control in organ donation is almost entirely regional, not national. States differ in how they define death, with subtle differences in what they adopt from the Uniform Determination of Death Act — which, despite the title, is a non-binding text that serves as a guide for state legislators.

Organizational participation rates in organ retrieval and distribution are uneven. In Making Health Care Decisions, Sr. Pat Talone cites a Joint Commission statistic that 80 percent of donations are from 20 percent of all U.S. hospitals. Healthcare and organ procurement organizations must partner and engineer specific contracts and protocols for organ donation. Ideally, these support chaplains providing guidance, for instance, by ensuring that living donors aren’t coerced.

“Honor walks” are a contemporary ritual in which hospital staff members line corridors as the patient or body is wheeled from the hospital room to the OR, often with family members accompanying to show support. While the practice is almost universally lauded, a presentation at the American Society for Bioethics and Humanities raised concerns about real-life blunders. Failures to emotionally prepare family members, to have informed consent discussions, and to discuss video recording and online posting have all caused harm. Chaplains are uniquely situated and skilled to address these challenges within healthcare organizations.

The direction provided by the U.S. bishops in the Ethical and Religious Directives for Catholic Health Care Services exemplifies the mutual complementarity of faith and science. Organ donation directives support the role for medical expertise (e.g., determining death) and “commonly accepted scientific criteria” as well as informed consent, preventing conflicts of interest, and “encouraging and providing means” for donation. Emphasizing this reciprocity can quickly ameliorate misunderstandings, such as the myth that organ donation is somehow anti-Catholic.

Individual
Chaplains may encounter patients and family members who need help framing the decision to donate organs. For living donors, Benedict Ashley, Jean deBlois, and Kevin O’Rourke recommend using the following conditions in Health Care Ethics: A Catholic Theological Analysis, 5th Ed.:

1) The recipient’s need “cannot be fulfilled in any other way.”
2) The donor’s functional integrity “will not be impaired, even though anatomical integrity can suffer.”
3) The risk of the donor’s act of charity “is proportionate” to the recipient’s good result.
4) Both the donor and recipient have “free and informed” consent.


A useful lens for these terms is a benefits/burdens analysis using Directives 27, 56, and 57. Family members of deceased donors may have misperceptions, sometimes before their loved one’s death. The “Organ donation: Don’t let these myths confuse you” webpage by the Mayo Clinic attends to common myths, including misconceptions that families will be charged for donation and that organ donors cannot have open-casket funeral. Having correct information may mitigate emotional and spiritual distress.

Patients and family members may have concerns about organ donation, religion, and for some, salvation. The Mayo Clinic says, “organ donation is consistent with the beliefs of most major religions” and specific questions can go to the patient’s clergy. Accurate information may not eliminate all distress, especially in the midst of grief. It is then that chaplains can model Pope Francis’ accompaniment during an encounter so that patients and family members can, in the words of Directive 55, receive “spiritual support … in order to prepare well for death.”

Steven J. Squires, PhD, MA, Med, is vice president of ethics at Bon Secours Mercy Health in Cincinnati.


About Vision
Archive of back issues

Current issue
Current issue (printable PDF)



Organ Donation: Choice, gift, and ministry

More people considering organ donation while alive – by David Lichter, Executive Director

Pastorally sensitive process helps families understand neurological death – by D.W. Donovan

When the gift can’t be received: The double loss of organ rejection – by Anne M. Windholz

Organ procurement groups can collaborate with chaplains – by Kelly Edwards, Gift of Life Donor Program

Advance directives make ideal time to plan organ donation – by James L. Robinson

Priest’s gift of kidney to parishioner gives everyone new outlook on life – by Rev. Martin J. Bancroft, Jr.

Ethics of organ donation range across many realms – by Steven J. Squires

Weight of history works against African-American donations – by Daniel Waters

End of life and organ donation may look different to Muslims – by Rev. Alejandro De Jesus

Parents choose to share their son with others in need – by Colette Hanlon

Research literature sheds light on organ donation process – by Austine Duru

Dementia communication tools will benefit professionals – by Anne M. Windholz

National Association of Catholic Chaplains
4915 S. Howell Avenue, Suite 501
Milwaukee, WI 53207
Get Directions

Phone: (414) 483-4898
Fax: (414) 483-6712
Email: info@nacc.org

Our office hours
Mon-Thur 8:00am – 5:00pm Central Time
Friday 8:00am – 12 Noon
Sat-Sun closed

Job Listings

Current job opportunities for chaplains, priests, CPE residents, supervisors, directors of pastoral care, managers, mission directors, and more.

Job Listings

Free Publications

Don’t miss the latest news, subscribe to our newsletter today! You don’t have to be a member to subscribe.

Donate Now

Learn more about making a tax-deductible donation to NACC.

Donate Now

Connect with us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • YouTube
© 1997 - 2023 National Association of Catholic Chaplains - Sitemap

Built by Westwords